url: https://youtu.be/HLMhoLHYzIA?t=3004

  • Christian Evangelicals and Trump | William R. Black & John Fea

    <iframe width=”560″ height=”315″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/HLMhoLHYzIA” frameborder=”0″ allow=”accelerometer; autoplay; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture” allowfullscreen></iframe>

    talking about the rabid Pro Trumper you
    48:34
    know the
    48:35
    you know the poll of whites of the world
    48:38
    Paula white I think firmly believes that
    48:40
    he’s a Christian and and God is using
    48:42
    him as a Christian to carry out you know
    48:46
    the purposes of the gospel or the church
    48:49
    in the world there’s others for example
    48:51
    someone like Robert Jeffress from the
    48:55
    pastor of the First Baptist Church in
    48:56
    Dallas or even Franklin Graham the son
    49:00
    of the evangelist Billy Clayton
    49:02
    evangelist Billy Graham who would say
    49:04
    sure Trump has his problem sure Trump is
    49:06
    a sinner I don’t know if Trump has
    49:08
    accepted Jesus as his Savior or not but
    49:12
    God like Cyrus God uses imperfect people
    49:17
    to carry out his plan so so they would
    49:22
    say it really does you know they would
    49:23
    say really doesn’t matter whether
    49:25
    Trump’s a Christian or not he is faith
    49:28
    friendly and God is using him in this
    49:31
    kind of incredible way God uses sinners
    49:34
    and God uses you know people who you
    49:39
    know have these corrupt lives or immoral
    49:41
    eyes to carry out his purposes God’s
    49:43
    ways are not our ways would be the
    49:45
    arguing and while we well we would think
    49:48
    that it should be a godly Christian
    49:50
    leader to help us sometimes God has
    49:52
    other plans would be the idea here so so
    49:55
    you get you got a kind of mixed mixed
    49:58
    views on that depending on which pro
    50:00
    Trump evangelical you talk to but you
    50:04
    know and I minded I grew up hearing a
    50:06
    lot of people who were evangelicals
    50:08
    saying something those basically the
    50:10
    reverse about Jimmy Carter were there
    50:13
    where they would completely grant that
    Jimmy Carter was was a you know and
    devout then but even even argue that he
    was a bad president because he was a
    good Christian to be a good president
    because he was done you know kick ass
    and take names I guess I don’t know
    50:31
    you’ve encountered during Carter Carter
    50:34
    is interesting because evangelicals did
    50:36
    flock to him in 1976 you know he might
    50:40
    stop supporting that just ants they
    50:42
    voted for Carter in 76 and 80
    50:45
    I mean an aphid errol’s Ford
    50:49
    seventy-six claimed to be some kind of
    50:51
    an evangelical Christian too so that’s
    50:52
    very interesting but the Carter was so
    50:54
    kind of authentic right he he he talked
    50:57
    about being born again
    50:59
    even his even his uh even his statement
    51:02
    about like being tempted to lust from
    51:04
    you know from women you know was was it
    51:09
    appealed to certain evangelicals right
    51:11
    you know that this guy’s honest truly he
    51:13
    meant they knew at length nobody and I
    51:16
    think I think what happened was when
    51:19
    Carter several things I mean one just
    51:22
    you know you can’t count out the economy
    51:24
    you know the recession and so forth also
    51:27
    Carter just did not deliver on the
    51:29
    things that evangelicals hoped he would
    51:32
    we talked earlier about the green calmly
    to Bob Jones case Jimmy Carter supported
    to Bob the supreme court on that he
    wanted to desegregate these academies
    and this this you know there was
    opposition that emerged almost
    immediately to Carter when it didn’t
    look like he would deliver on abortion
    overturn roe v– wade you know try to
    try to try to keep the keep the
    segregation in place in these academies
    so uh you know this is where Falwell and
    others so many of you know the story
    many our listeners will own story this
    is where Falwell and others kind of say
    no we thought this guy was was one you
    know was going to help our moral cause
    and he doesn’t seem to be doing it so uh
    so yeah Carter’s a car is a fascinating
    character I think it’s probably you know
    it’s probably true to say the fact that
    he tried to actually live out a kind of
    authentic evangelicalism probably did uh
    you know hurt his his presidency I mean
    he has that famous 1979 malaise speech
    in wrench you know he says we are a
    52:36
    nation that is self-centered selfish we
    52:40
    only care about each other we don’t
    52:41
    think about the common good you know and
    52:43
    then Reagan comes in and just says you
    52:45
    know do whatever you want right
    52:47
    individualism freedom right you know
    52:50
    freedom of religion they love these
    52:52
    kinds of things no I felt this message
    52:55
    of self-discipline that Carter puts
    52:57
    forth which you know is this
    52:59
    authentically Christian message but you
    53:01
    know that’s I think
    53:02
    says a lot about the evangelical
    53:04
    electorate as well I have one more
    53:07
    question that you will wrap up but I I
    53:12
    know you know there’s been debates in
    53:15
    the Democratic Party about you know
    53:17
    what’s the right calculus to to defeat
    53:21
    Trump in 2020 and you know one sidebar
    53:27
    in that debate is how much should they
    53:30
    try and win over people who voted for
    53:33
    Trump yeah yeah and a part of that is
    53:38
    you know it is it worth trying to talk
    53:41
    to some evangelicals to vote for Trump
    53:43
    and to appeal to them you know appeal to
    53:49
    their values there professor
    53:52
    what do you think about that yeah yeah I
    53:55
    mean I wrote a whole book about this so
    53:57
    I hope yours I hope there’s a
    53:59
    possibility but I see I see those
    54:01
    eighty-one percent as as very you know
    54:03
    there’s there’s diversity within that 81
    54:05
    percent one of the things I worry about
    54:07
    with this with the media is that they
    54:09
    don’t see the diversity of 81 percent
    54:12
    that 81 percent includes the rabid Trump
    54:16
    supporters who are evangelicals the
    54:18
    people who go to the rallies the people
    54:20
    who supported this guy in the primaries
    54:22
    when there were other options
    54:24
    the GOP primaries the people who wear
    54:26
    the manga hats you know I mean there’s a
    54:29
    lot of Evangelicals you know I remember
    54:30
    I remember when Trump came to Harrisburg
    54:33
    Pennsylvania I’m watching the news
    54:36
    coverage on it at night you know local
    54:37
    news coverage and you know I see like
    54:40
    four or five people from my church in
    54:42
    line my evangelical church in line right
    54:45
    so there’s that group what I found after
    doing close to 20 or 30 book talks and
    and I’m on the road a lot with this book
    is that many of those people are just
    not going to be convinced by kind of
    rational arguments you know politics is
    often so much emotional and and and it’s
    just gonna be hard to convince those
    people however there’s a large large
    55:10
    number and I don’t know what the
    55:11
    percentage is but but I also find
    55:13
    there’s a large number who just don’t
    55:14
    like Donald Trump they wish
    55:16
    they didn’t have to vote for him they
    55:18
    hated Hillary Clinton even more they
    55:22
    were they they kind of walked the line
    55:24
    between not voting for the president and
    55:26
    voting for Trump right or voting for a
    55:30
    third party candidate and voting for
    55:33
    Trump and they decided that they were
    55:34
    going to vote for Trump it’s those kind
    55:36
    of people that I hope my book is going
    55:38
    to reach you know and get them to sort
    55:42
    of rethink you know especially in light
    55:44
    of everything that’s happened since
    55:46
    Trump’s been elected all of the kind of
    55:49
    misogyny and racist Arbenz a comet if
    55:53
    charlottesville he has an awful
    55:54
    immigration policy and so forth on the
    55:57
    other hand you can’t count out the
    56:00
    economy right the economy is doing
    56:02
    really really well a lot of youth
    56:03
    angelica’s may not vote on moral issues
    56:06
    they may vote on economic issues in 2020
    56:08
    but when you think about it this way
    56:10
    right you don’t need too many
    56:11
    evangelicals to have their minds changed
    56:14
    for for for a Democrat to win in 2020 I
    56:19
    mean Hillary won by three million votes
    56:22
    the popular vote so so you know in
    56:26
    places like Pennsylvania which you know
    56:29
    where we saw in the 2018 midterms we saw
    56:33
    mostly Democratic candidates being
    56:35
    elected governor senator the the conquer
    56:40
    Congress seats almost all many of them
    56:42
    flipped to Democrat you know place like
    56:46
    Michigan and Wisconsin you don’t need
    56:48
    too many votes to turn those states back
    56:50
    towards a Democratic candidate so I’m
    56:52
    not you know I’m kind of you know a lot
    56:56
    of people are saying well if the
    56:57
    economy’s good Trump’s gonna win again
    56:59
    I’m not entirely convinced about that at
    57:02
    least if you can turn some evangelicals
    57:04
    you know you might you might have a
    57:06
    chance to knock him off in 2020 well
    57:09
    here’s here’s a question then if if the
    57:14
    Democrats have a nominee who is more
    57:17
    likable than Hillary Clinton yeah do you
    57:20
    think at least there’ll be sizeable you
    57:23
    know statistically significant number
    57:26
    vocals who will at
    57:28
    perhaps not vote for the Democrat but
    57:30
    feel like they don’t have to vote for
    57:32
    Khurana
    57:32
    yeah Hillary Clinton is a problem with
    57:35
    the problem for white conservative
    57:36
    evangelicals for two reasons one is one
    57:40
    is one as she represents everything
    57:42
    about sort of what white evangelicals
    57:45
    see as progressivism right pretty
    57:47
    pro-choice not doing much to defend
    57:50
    Christian values religious liberty
    57:52
    particularly marriage you know she’s big
    57:56
    government and so forth any Democratic
    57:58
    candidate that runs is going to have
    58:00
    those same problems with white
    58:01
    evangelicals unless it’s like a pro-life
    58:05
    democrat right that’s like Bob Casey
    58:07
    from Pennsylvania runs who completely
    58:10
    who evangelicals backed over Rick
    58:12
    Santorum right and then drove Rick
    58:14
    Santorum out this is my home state so I
    58:16
    know these races pretty well the other
    58:20
    problem the other problem white
    58:21
    evangelicals had with Hillary Clinton
    58:22
    was that she was Hillary Clinton you
    58:24
    know the baggage going back to the bill
    58:27
    scandals with Monica Lewinsky going back
    58:30
    to the lying the you know she’s saying
    58:33
    right-wing conspiracy and blah blah blah
    58:36
    the deplorable slide you know nobody
    58:39
    Clinton made a lot of mistakes among
    58:41
    white evangelicals I don’t think I don’t
    58:43
    think if she corrected those mistakes
    58:45
    she would have won over many white
    58:46
    evangelicals to her side but she may
    58:48
    have turned some white evangelicals away
    58:51
    from Donald Trump towards a third party
    58:53
    candidate or towards just not voting in
    58:56
    the presidential election so you know
    58:59
    we’ll see what happens you could have a
    59:01
    Democrat who and if it’s a traditional
    59:05
    Democrat on the moral questions that
    59:07
    Emma Jellico’s hold dear in 2020 I just
    59:11
    I think I think they’re still gonna
    59:14
    they’re not gonna vote for that Democrat
    59:16
    but because it’s not Hillary Clinton
    59:18
    they may say well we could put up with
    59:19
    this guy or this one as opposed to you
    59:23
    know their four years of Trump I heard
    59:26
    something you said this but someone
    59:29
    compared Hillary Clinton’s sort of
    59:33
    relationship as a cultural icon to the
    59:37
    women’s rights movement to Jesse
    59:39
    Jackson’s relationship to the civil
    59:41
    and the argument was that in the same
    59:47
    way that Jesse Jackson couldn’t become
    59:50
    president because of just all the
    59:53
    baggage that comes with being part of
    59:54
    that generation yeah someone from the
    59:59
    second generation like Obama didn’t have
    60:01
    that package
    60:02
    yeah next woman right is the argument
    60:07
    that I’ve heard from women’s rights
    60:11
    movement but not be associated with all
    60:14
    the baggage came with having to fight
    60:16
    that fight yeah no no six or seven yeah
    60:19
    yeah no it’s there’s probably some truth
    60:21
    to that we’ll see you know I don’t know
    60:24
    how many women candidates are out there
    60:25
    you hear about come out Kamala Harris
    60:28
    Kristin Gillibrand I mean you know we’ll
    60:32
    see what happens I’m not sure well I I
    60:37
    forgot to mention the start but I will
    60:39
    plug you are you run a great blog that’s
    60:43
    also the title of your first book and
    60:46
    the title of your podcast which is right
    60:48
    the way of improvement leads home which
    60:53
    what’s the URL is it way of improvement
    60:56
    way of improvement calm way of
    60:59
    improvement calm or no that’s instead
    61:06
    Zealand yes I encourage people check out
    61:17
    your blog your podcast and you tweet at
    61:22
    John fear one john thea one yep jo hn f
    61:28
    EI one yeah and i tweet at william are
    61:35
    black and in your book believe me the
    61:39
    evangelical road to Donald Trump would
    61:42
    be a good stocking stuffer when you have
    61:47
    those conversations at Christmas right I
    61:49
    did a promo for the book on I tweeted I
    61:52
    said you just got done with these
    61:53
    conversations over Thanks
    61:55
    giving with your pro-trump evangelical
    61:57
    friends and you wish you had some more
    61:58
    arguments for when Christmas or the
    62:00
    December holidays come around right get
    62:03
    this book you have a month to read it in
    62:05
    preparation for Christmas dinner or
    62:07
    whatever it might be well thanks for
    62:12
    coming on I love to have you on again
    62:14
    sometime and great thanks for having me
    62:17
    bill thank you